Middlebury, CT Real Estate Market Report: Price Trends and Data Analysis

or Create your own market report
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
775 South St 8 8 9,619 $2,850,000 $296 205 days
397 White Deer Rock Rd 3 3 3,863 $2,195,000 $568 133 days
67 Abbott Farms Rd 4 4 5,237 $1,399,900 $267 21 days
135 Washington Dr 4 4 3,485 $999,000 $286 12 days
9 Whitehall Ct 4 5 4,261 $979,900 $229 0 days
552 Breakneck Hill Rd 5 4 4,114 $950,000 $230 30 days
25 Avalon Dr 3 4 3,494 $879,900 $251 86 days
6 Deer Run Rd 3 3 2,190 $849,900 $388 353 days
29 Cambridge Ct 3 3 2,796 $829,900 $296 17 days
18 Hunting Ridge Rd 4 3 2,700 $819,000 $303 9 days
20 Hunting Ridge Rd 3 2 1,877 $774,900 $412 178 days
117 Crest Rd 4 3 2,753 $750,000 $272 249 days
77 Crest Rd 4 4 2,674 $749,900 $280 32 days
80 Pine Hollow Dr 4 4 2,806 $724,900 $258 170 days
46 Washington Dr 4 4 1,940 $675,000 $347 14 days
10 Curtis Rd 4 3 2,484 $670,000 $269 60 days
90 Fenn Rd 4 4 3,162 $660,000 $208 141 days
70 Pine Hollow Dr 3 3 3,174 $649,900 $204 84 days
168 N Farm Rd 4 4 3,302 $649,900 $196 97 days
16 Caveson Court, Unit 16 3 3 1,957 $600,000 $306 15 days
16 Caveson Court, Unit 16 3 3 1,957 $600,000 $306 15 days
58 Shadduck Rd 3 3 2,360 $599,900 $254 9 days
3 Brookside Dr Unit 3 4 4 4,200 $599,900 $142 258 days
3 Brookside Dr Unit 3 4 4 4,200 $599,900 $142 258 days
700 Watertown Rd 4 3 2,528 $590,000 $233 87 days
66 Artillery Rd 4 4 2,691 $585,000 $217 151 days
2 Northwood Dr 3 3 1,700 $575,000 $338 60 days
123 Northwood Dr 3 3 1,552 $539,000 $347 42 days
323 Watertown Rd 4 3 2,067 $539,000 $260 45 days
4 Kimberwick Ct Unit 4 3 3 2,181 $534,900 $245 65 days
4 Kimberwick Ct Unit 4 3 3 2,181 $534,900 $245 65 days
10 Ridgewood Dr Unit 10 3 3 2,403 $529,900 $220 74 days
326 Lake Shore Dr 3 2 1,568 $520,000 $331 59 days
89 Sandy Beach Road Unit 89 2 1 798 $499,900 $626 10 days
112 Joy Rd 3 2 1,900 $499,900 $263 43 days
251 Lake Shore Dr 3 2 2,568 $499,000 $194 35 days
213 Acme Dr 4 3 1,833 $499,000 $272 67 days
106 Steinmann Ave 4 2 1,630 $479,900 $294 22 days
133 Algin Dr 3 3 1,837 $474,900 $258 15 days
47 Middlebury Ter 2 2 1,953 $474,500 $242 44 days
42 White Ave 3 3 2,112 $449,900 $213 56 days
1140 Southford Rd N/A N/A N/A $399,000 Unknown 167 days
138 Steinmann Ave 3 2 1,466 $350,000 $238 7 days
24 Yale Ave 3 2 1,469 $349,900 $238 41 days
12 Yale Ave 2 1 836 $339,900 $406 51 days
125 Shadduck Rd 2 2 1,008 $324,900 $322 50 days
327 Steinmann Ave 2 1 676 $300,000 $443 3 days
75 Gleneagle Rd N/A N/A N/A $249,900 Unknown 219 days
500 Watertown Rd N/A N/A N/A $229,000 Unknown 31 days
35 Nutmeg Rd Unit B2 1 1 889 $224,900 $252 16 days
Average: 3.4 3.0 2,562 $672,978 $285 80 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 50
Viewing 1 - 50 of 50
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
625 Charcoal Ave 3 3 4,236 $945,000 $223 24 days
Lot 41 Somerset 3 3 2,878 $939,000 $326 182 days
19 Deer Run Rd 4 3 3,100 $900,000 $290 164 days
8 Deer Run Rd 3 3 2,450 $839,900 $342 95 days
15 Hunting Ridge Rd 3 3 1,877 $779,900 $415 548 days
3 Pine Ridge, Unit 23 2 3 2,290 $721,000 $314 536 days
179 Burr Hall Rd 4 3 3,938 $675,000 $171 42 days
285 Southford Rd 3 2 2,007 $650,000 $323 14 days
130 Fairhaven Dr 3 3 2,654 $649,900 $244 51 days
North Benson Rd Unit 63 3 3 2,251 $612,553 $272 7 days
North Benson Rd Unit 61 3 3 1,950 $608,700 $312 7 days
North Benson Rd Unit 58 3 3 2,582 $608,000 $235 37 days
North Benson Rd Unit 48 3 3 2,706 $603,780 $223 352 days
North Benson Rd Unit 60 3 3 2,206 $573,584 $260 311 days
North Benson Rd Unit 65 3 3 2,206 $573,572 $260 114 days
North Benson Rd Unit 56 3 3 2,206 $572,000 $259 81 days
North Benson Rd Unit 54 3 3 2,349 $570,600 $242 53 days
North Benson Rd Unit 59 3 3 2,206 $568,564 $257 403 days
North Benson Rd Unit 66 3 3 1,950 $562,350 $288 72 days
North Benson Rd Unit 57 3 3 2,206 $561,271 $254 270 days
North Benson Rd Unit 52 3 3 2,206 $560,753 $254 468 days
North Benson Rd Unit 44 3 3 1,950 $559,250 $286 58 days
North Benson Rd Unit 44 3 3 2,252 $555,888 $246 430 days
85 Blueberry Knls 3 2 2,156 $550,000 $255 29 days
North Benson Rd Unit 55 3 3 2,462 $548,828 $222 522 days
North Benson Rd Unit 62 3 3 2,206 $545,400 $247 218 days
North Benson Rd Unit 64 3 3 2,206 $545,400 $247 561 days
North Benson Rd Unit 49 3 3 1,950 $533,416 $273 485 days
North Benson Rd Unit 45 3 3 1,950 $525,438 $269 512 days
North Benson Rd Unit 51 3 3 1,950 $523,920 $268 401 days
North Benson Rd Unit 46 3 3 1,950 $522,128 $267 480 days
North Benson Rd Unit 53 3 3 1,950 $519,900 $266 522 days
North Benson Rd Unit 47 3 3 2,206 $509,900 $231 470 days
North Benson Rd Unit 50 3 3 1,950 $509,900 $261 395 days
555 Whittemore Rd 4 3 1,855 $449,000 $242 99 days
1252 Straits Tpke 4 1 1,848 $299,900 $162 93 days
Average: 3.1 2.9 2,313 $604,824 $264 253 days
Viewing 1 - 36 of 36
Viewing 1 - 36 of 36
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
7-11 Sandy Beach Rd 6 4 5,816 $4,100,000 $4,050,000 $696 101 days 1/15/26
82 Mirey Dam Rd 4 3 3,471 $970,000 $975,000 $280 45 days 11/17/25
851 South St 5 3 3,301 $950,000 $937,500 $284 76 days 6/30/26
286 Mirey Dam Rd 4 3 4,451 $975,000 $900,000 $202 41 days 7/9/26
383 Leonard Rd 4 5 3,220 $889,900 $895,000 $277 82 days 2/11/26
171 Judd Hill Rd 5 4 3,700 $899,950 $882,500 $238 98 days 9/25/25
245 Upper Whittemore 3 3 2,990 $815,000 $875,000 $292 60 days 6/15/26
122 Crest Rd 3 3 3,253 $825,000 $850,000 $261 79 days 7/7/26
11 Hunting Ridge Rd 4 3 2,700 $799,900 $820,000 $303 423 days 12/18/25
38 Avalon Dr 3 3 3,217 $779,000 $815,000 $253 51 days 7/29/26
18 Deer Run Rd 3 3 2,190 $799,900 $810,000 $369 346 days 5/8/26
1 Hampshire Ct 4 4 3,711 $829,000 $800,000 $215 99 days 12/16/25
64 Watertown Rd 3 4 4,094 $759,900 $759,900 $185 78 days 6/30/26
366 Charcoal Ave 4 3 3,198 $750,000 $750,000 $234 73 days 5/27/26
28 Hunting Ridge Rd 4 3 2,466 $729,900 $740,000 $300 548 days 9/9/26
200 N Farm Rd 4 4 3,360 $750,000 $728,000 $216 39 days 5/8/26
111 Dwyer Rd 3 3 3,212 $717,000 $710,000 $221 171 days 12/18/25
2 Deer Run Rd 3 3 2,190 $709,900 $709,900 $324 232 days 2/27/26
15 Central Rd 3 3 2,870 $694,900 $706,000 $245 63 days 6/30/26
14 Deer Run Rd 3 2 1,877 $699,000 $699,900 $372 323 days 3/3/26
18 Winding Trail, Unit 18 3 5 4,051 $700,000 $695,000 $171 96 days 11/21/25
84 Munson Rd 4 5 3,254 $689,000 $675,000 $207 161 days 6/8/26
55 Westwood Dr 4 3 2,570 $695,000 $675,000 $262 198 days 9/24/25
36 Independence Cir 4 4 3,512 $650,000 $670,000 $190 74 days 8/31/26
223 Carriage Dr 4 4 2,484 $674,900 $670,000 $269 103 days 6/30/26
117 Periwinkle Dr Unit 117 3 4 3,488 $669,900 $669,900 $192 61 days 11/12/25
200 Northridge Dr 3 3 2,360 $650,000 $650,000 $275 44 days 8/28/26
51 Cross Rd 4 4 3,244 $629,900 $645,000 $198 63 days 1/27/26
1 Independence Cir Unit 1 4 3 3,224 $609,000 $630,000 $195 47 days 7/7/26
10 Pelham Way Unit 10 3 3 2,251 $650,000 $625,000 $277 60 days 6/30/26
16 Winding Trail, Unit 16 3 3 2,646 $625,000 $625,000 $236 37 days 4/10/26
193 Ridgewood Dr Unit 193 3 3 2,658 $649,900 $620,000 $233 51 days 5/28/26
3 Hunting Ridge Rd 3 3 1,722 $629,900 $620,000 $360 39 days 3/30/26
408 Breakneck Hill Rd 2 3 1,848 $625,000 $615,000 $332 77 days 6/29/26
1 Independence Cir Unit 1 4 3 3,224 $620,000 $615,000 $190 153 days 10/30/25
178 Ridgewood Dr Unit 178 3 3 2,414 $639,900 $607,000 $251 45 days 7/7/26
321 Artillery Rd 4 3 3,300 $699,990 $602,500 $182 159 days 8/3/26
72 Carriage Dr 4 3 2,878 $649,900 $600,000 $208 197 days 4/21/26
39 Independence Cir Unit 39 4 4 3,382 $619,900 $600,000 $177 146 days 11/14/25
428 Breakneck Hill Rd 2 2 1,749 $599,900 $599,900 $342 68 days 5/1/26
North Benson Rd Unit 40 3 3 1,950 $509,300 $593,360 $304 278 days 10/10/25
126 Colonial Ave 3 2 2,531 $599,000 $585,000 $231 152 days 1/29/26
36 Highridge Road Unit 36 3 3 1,997 $585,000 $580,000 $290 164 days 9/10/26
2 Arrowwood Ct Unit 2 3 3 2,256 $599,900 $575,000 $254 88 days 7/10/26
1 Dogwood Ct Unit 1 3 4 3,477 $610,000 $575,000 $165 216 days 11/6/25
292 Park Rd Extension 5 2 1,924 $574,900 $574,900 $298 142 days 5/4/26
72 Ridgewood Dr Unit 72 3 3 2,428 $569,900 $569,900 $234 59 days 7/29/26
1 Arrowwood Ct Unit 1 3 3 2,295 $569,500 $569,500 $248 105 days 6/12/26
23 Caveson Court, Unit 23 3 3 2,547 $565,000 $565,000 $221 73 days 1/2/26
27 Winding Trail, Unit 27 3 3 2,680 $565,000 $565,000 $210 89 days 1/14/26
Average: 3.2 2.8 2,347 $592,284 $587,651 $260 127 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 106
Viewing 1 - 50 of 106

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2026 SmartMLS, Inc.