Middletown, CT Real Estate Market Report: Price Trends and Data Analysis

or Create your own market report
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
423 Main St N/A 4 39,000 $4,500,000 $115 47 days
668 Main St N/A 21 11,232 $2,249,500 $200 81 days
942 Washington St N/A 2 2,048 $1,700,000 $830 89 days
51-57 S Main St N/A 1 8,390 $1,695,000 $202 145 days
480 Main St N/A 10 13,837 $1,300,000 $93 42 days
480 Main St 8 10 13,837 $1,300,000 $93 42 days
13-15 Portland St 12 8 9,890 $1,300,000 $131 61 days
13 Portland St N/A 8 9,890 $1,300,000 $131 75 days
516 Washington St Unit 1 N/A N/A 5,115 $1,299,000 $253 21 days
1409 Millbrook Rd 4 4 2,656 $1,295,000 $487 29 days
Portland Street 8 4 5,176 $1,100,000 $212 115 days
Portland Street N/A 1 5,176 $1,100,000 $212 115 days
575 Main St Unit STE 2 N/A N/A 7,814 $999,999 $127 298 days
49 Partridge Ln 4 5 4,234 $999,000 $235 31 days
504 Main St N/A 10 N/A $975,000 Unknown 287 days
Scovill Rd N/A N/A N/A $950,000 Unknown 75 days
54 Washington St N/A N/A 12,288 $935,000 $76 297 days
193 Scarborough Ln 4 5 3,576 $899,900 $251 37 days
29 Copper Beech Dr 5 4 3,452 $849,900 $246 64 days
44 Chamberlain Hill Rd 6 4 5,599 $829,000 $148 161 days
236 Maple Shade Rd 3 3 3,283 $759,000 $231 14 days
Middle St N/A N/A N/A $750,000 Unknown 194 days
227 E Main St 9 6 3,180 $749,900 $235 89 days
110 Freeman Rd 4 2 2,070 $699,999 $338 91 days
166 Mccormick Ln 4 3 2,876 $688,000 $239 4 days
27 Pleasant St N/A N/A 3,314 $679,900 $205 73 days
72 Annello Way 4 3 2,734 $650,000 $237 57 days
362 Industrial Park Rd Unit 5 N/A 3 8,545 $650,000 $76 82 days
76 Thimble Rock Rd 4 4 2,671 $649,900 $243 45 days
145 Webster Ln Unit 2-41 2 2 1,555 $649,900 $417 285 days
609 Newfield St N/A 2 2,028 $599,609 $295 175 days
137 Webster Ln Unit 2-42 2 2 1,430 $589,900 $412 328 days
650 Ridgewood Rd 3 2 1,452 $589,000 $405 69 days
26 Tuscany Hills Dr Unit 26 2 2 1,708 $550,000 $322 25 days
Lot 3a Nathan Hale 3 3 1,761 $549,900 $312 59 days
1512 Country Club Rd 3 3 1,604 $539,999 $336 3 days
1175 S Main St 3 2 1,814 $525,000 $289 46 days
1020 Bartholomew Rd 3 3 1,952 $524,900 $268 49 days
67 Bell St 3 2 2,398 $499,900 $208 38 days
Lot 2 Nathan Hale 3 2 1,540 $499,900 $324 60 days
Lot 3 Nathan Hale 3 2 1,540 $499,900 $324 138 days
779 Ridge Rd 3 3 2,642 $480,000 $181 19 days
25 Pleasant View Dr 3 3 2,030 $479,900 $236 91 days
110 Coe Ave N/A 2 1,281 $479,900 $374 650 days
1258 Saybrook Rd 3 2 2,106 $449,900 $213 21 days
598 High St 3 2 1,714 $437,900 $255 24 days
9 Round Hill Rd 3 3 2,067 $430,000 $208 16 days
85 Ten Acre Rd 3 3 2,016 $425,000 $210 10 days
163 Pearl St 6 2 2,982 $420,000 $140 26 days
71 E Main St 9 5 3,110 $419,000 $134 19 days
Average: 3.6 3.0 3,277 $614,817 $237 82 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 95
Viewing 1 - 50 of 95
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
530 Main St 1 1 11,033 $1,500,000 $135 107 days
530 Main St N/A 1 15,136 $1,500,000 $99 110 days
37 Cranberry Ln 3 4 3,644 $619,000 $169 63 days
46 Tavern Cir 4 4 4,132 $599,900 $145 34 days
265 Briarwood Ln 3 3 3,036 $559,900 $184 74 days
18-A Talcott Ridge Dr 3 2 1,850 $549,000 $296 816 days
175 Rolling Grn 4 3 3,363 $499,999 $148 19 days
Lot 1 Nathan Hale 3 2 1,540 $499,900 $324 60 days
Lot 4 Nathan Hale 3 2 1,540 $499,900 $324 138 days
315 E Ridge Rd 3 3 2,645 $499,000 $188 47 days
46 Bretton Rd 4 4 3,622 $497,900 $137 59 days
117 David Dr 3 3 1,826 $485,000 $265 32 days
364 Coleman Rd 3 2 1,805 $475,000 $263 21 days
737 Newfield St N/A 3 4,956 $475,000 $95 88 days
15 Mulberry Ln 3 3 1,813 $465,000 $256 17 days
408 Maromas Rd 3 2 2,176 $465,000 $213 94 days
58 Brown St 3 3 1,456 $459,900 $315 67 days
East Mount Road N/A N/A N/A $450,000 Unknown 763 days
38 Sylvan Dr 3 3 2,100 $450,000 $214 34 days
65 Prout Hill Rd 3 2 1,654 $435,000 $262 42 days
38 Wildflower Ln 2 3 1,860 $414,900 $223 24 days
390 Ballfall Rd 3 3 2,092 $399,900 $191 45 days
656 Bartholomew Rd Unit 656 2 3 1,350 $399,900 $296 69 days
82 Wilcox Rd 3 2 1,513 $399,000 $263 70 days
74 Johnson St 5 3 2,848 $375,000 $131 49 days
72 Durant Ter 3 3 1,446 $375,000 $259 68 days
193 Ridge Rd 3 2 1,525 $369,900 $242 22 days
58 Durant Ter 4 2 1,754 $369,900 $210 324 days
116 Schuyler Ave 3 2 1,470 $359,000 $244 17 days
66 East St 3 2 1,514 $349,900 $231 31 days
30 Snipes Ter 3 3 1,654 $349,000 $211 45 days
36 Hunting Hill Ave 2 2 1,157 $330,000 $285 39 days
31 Burr Ave 2 2 1,470 $330,000 $224 75 days
38 Harris St 3 2 1,894 $324,900 $171 80 days
87 Lewis St 3 1 1,361 $319,000 $234 33 days
57 Ridge Rd 3 1 1,412 $300,000 $212 47 days
118 Grove St 3 2 1,926 $300,000 $155 81 days
234 S Main St Unit 416 2 3 1,450 $285,000 $196 93 days
65 Deerfield Ave 2 1 912 $273,000 $299 34 days
6 Hillside Ct 3 2 1,299 $270,000 $207 151 days
146 Liberty St 3 2 1,340 $249,609 $186 166 days
10 Countryside Ln Unit 1 2 2 1,132 $245,000 $216 15 days
17 Inverness Ln 3 1 1,209 $234,900 $194 54 days
78 Trolley Crossing Ln Unit 78 2 2 1,206 $224,900 $186 24 days
515 E Main St 2 2 1,463 $219,000 $149 35 days
Average: 2.9 2.3 2,445 $445,580 $215 97 days
Viewing 1 - 45 of 45
Viewing 1 - 45 of 45
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
120 Chamberlain Hill Rd 4 5 5,661 $1,900,000 $1,875,000 $331 81 days 12/22/25
35 Industrial Park Pl N/A 2 27,090 $1,400,000 $1,450,000 $53 107 days 7/20/26
138 Washington St N/A N/A 7,193 $1,100,000 $950,000 $132 158 days 3/27/26
12 Copper Beech Dr 4 4 4,393 $914,900 $920,000 $209 69 days 7/10/26
231 Scarborough Ln 5 3 3,236 $849,999 $861,000 $266 77 days 12/11/25
81 Aresco Dr 4 5 5,282 $834,900 $817,000 $154 30 days 1/8/26
66 Sachem Dr 5 5 4,560 $799,900 $803,000 $176 60 days 6/30/26
98 Ryefield Rd 3 6 4,863 $849,900 $800,000 $164 71 days 9/2/25
250 Atkins St 4 3 3,612 $799,000 $784,850 $217 350 days 10/23/25
33 Knoll Ridge Ct 4 3 3,054 $785,000 $770,000 $252 68 days 7/22/26
Lot 3 Sisk 3 3 2,151 $599,900 $762,004 $354 471 days 5/22/26
135 Saddle Hill Dr 5 3 3,083 $650,000 $760,000 $246 84 days 7/1/26
128 Webster Ln 2 2 1,555 $708,768 $747,925 $480 216 days 5/14/26
462 Higby Rd 4 3 2,500 $719,000 $725,000 $290 262 days 12/19/25
602-2 Higby Rd 5 3 2,602 $637,400 $720,093 $276 412 days 3/12/26
90 Tall Timbers Rd 4 4 2,580 $640,000 $720,000 $279 26 days 9/15/25
100 Round Hill Rd 3 3 2,824 $725,000 $715,000 $253 70 days 8/15/25
455 East St 5 3 3,010 $750,000 $700,000 $232 198 days 11/20/25
134 Webster Ln Unit 2-15 2 2 1,555 $685,144 $695,533 $447 164 days 2/12/26
87 Wanda Ln 4 3 4,385 $675,000 $675,000 $153 68 days 6/16/26
29 Talias Trl 4 3 2,432 $610,000 $673,000 $276 26 days 10/17/25
123 Webster Ln 2 2 1,555 $669,995 $672,353 $432 406 days 3/24/26
34 Apple Ln 6 5 4,096 $689,900 $665,000 $162 83 days 11/4/25
60 Watch Hill Dr 4 3 2,152 $675,000 $660,000 $306 48 days 7/8/26
220 Coleman Rd 3 3 2,562 $595,000 $660,000 $257 53 days 7/1/26
45 Serra Dr 4 3 3,750 $599,900 $660,000 $176 37 days 7/28/25
601 Higby Rd 3 3 2,214 $609,900 $647,730 $292 226 days 2/13/26
132 Webster Ln Unit 2-16 2 2 1,640 $630,727 $646,457 $394 279 days 7/31/25
886 East St 3 3 2,390 $650,000 $640,000 $267 176 days 5/29/26
44 Trailside Xing 4 3 2,356 $605,000 $635,000 $269 52 days 1/29/26
896 East St 3 3 2,400 $639,900 $634,000 $264 105 days 8/4/25
11 Mansfield Ter 6 4 3,148 $599,900 $625,000 $198 42 days 4/24/26
10 Talias Trl 4 3 2,285 $599,000 $620,000 $271 73 days 5/29/26
46 Sonoma Ln Unit 46 3 3 2,515 $649,900 $620,000 $246 88 days 9/26/25
46 Sonoma Ln Unit 46 3 3 2,515 $649,900 $620,000 $246 94 days 9/26/25
126 Webster Ln Unit 2-19 2 2 1,555 $613,047 $616,532 $396 192 days 7/30/25
67 Wildwood Ln 4 3 2,349 $611,000 $611,000 $260 56 days 6/1/26
11 Webster Ln Unit 6 3 3 2,309 $599,900 $610,000 $264 41 days 6/18/26
123 Round Hill Rd 3 2 2,064 $549,000 $600,000 $290 48 days 6/26/26
270 Higby Rd 4 3 2,844 $589,000 $600,000 $210 46 days 4/29/26
109 Red Clover Cir 3 3 3,456 $499,900 $600,000 $173 62 days 2/27/26
330 Coleman Rd 3 3 2,619 $559,900 $595,000 $227 51 days 2/27/26
36 Brookview Ln 4 3 3,792 $584,999 $595,000 $156 93 days 1/9/26
60 Sonoma Ln Unit 60 2 3 2,054 $549,900 $591,000 $287 66 days 4/6/26
5 Sonoma Ln Unit 5 2 3 1,840 $498,900 $590,000 $320 50 days 9/30/25
23 Falmouth Ct 5 3 2,760 $614,900 $585,000 $211 126 days 11/18/25
324 Washington St 6 3 2,636 $529,900 $582,000 $220 41 days 7/13/26
301 Bell St 3 4 3,853 $575,000 $575,000 $149 175 days 2/27/26
846 Arbutus St 3 3 2,573 $579,999 $575,000 $223 82 days 8/18/25
00 Villa St 3 2 1,600 $449,900 $575,000 $359 278 days 10/24/25
Average: 3.2 2.3 1,910 $389,342 $399,569 $229 68 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 458
Viewing 1 - 50 of 458

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2026 SmartMLS, Inc.