Moving to Connecticut? 8 Towns About to Cross $400,000 (#1 Is $5,000 Away)

So you're thinking of moving to Connecticut.

I'm Dave Jones with Dave Jones Realty, and these eight towns are under $400,000 — but not for long. If you set your search filter at $400,000, one of these towns may have already disappeared from it, because at the time I put this together it was $5,000 away.

I'm going to show you how close each one is, what the tax bill actually runs, and what you get before it crosses the line.

First — why $400,000 matters so much

The median is the middle house. Half sold for more, half sold for less.

So when a town's median is $395,000, almost half the houses in that town already sold over $400,000. You're only seeing half the town. And the day that median crosses, you're seeing less than half.

When I say a town is about to disappear from your search, I don't mean it vanishes overnight. It fades. Fewer houses every month, until one day the town just doesn't show up at all — and you never even knew it was an option.

How I picked these eight

I took every town in Connecticut and all the closed sales. I kept the ones with a median under $400,000. I threw out any town with fewer than 70 sales, because small towns swing far too much on a handful of transactions and you can't trust the number. Then I kept the ones moving fast enough to cross $400,000 in roughly a year.

Eight towns made it.

---

#8 — Rocky Hill: $365,000, and only 14 houses for sale

The median last year was $365,000. That's $35,000 under the line, which sounds like real room.

Here's the context. Rocky Hill was at $256,000 in 2021. It has added $109,000 in four years — about $27,000 a year. At that pace, $35,000 is roughly 15 months of runway. Not years.

And at the end of last year there were only 14 houses for sale in the entire town. That is a town with zero extra room in it.

What's actually in Rocky Hill

Back in 1966 a bulldozer operator digging the foundation for a new state building hit rock and uncovered dinosaur footprints — hundreds of them. Construction stopped, and the state built a giant dome over the tracks. Today you can walk right up and look at them. Dinosaur State Park is one of the coolest things in the whole state, and almost nobody outside Connecticut has heard of it.

The other thing Rocky Hill has is the ferry. The Rocky Hill–Glastonbury ferry has been running since 1655 and is the oldest continuously operating ferry in the country. Cars still drive onto it. In the summer you can cross the Connecticut River for a few dollars.

It's a small thing, but it tells you what kind of town this is. It's old. It's settled. People don't leave.

Rocky Hill is a town people drive right past on I-91, and you're about 15 minutes to downtown Hartford, right on the river, with Bradley Airport roughly half an hour up the road.

Taxes on the typical house run about $644 a month. That's an estimate, but it's a real number you can plan with.

One quick thing. If you want to see the actual houses for sale in these towns right now, go to searchallcthomes.com. It's a direct feed from the MLS, so it's more current than Zillow or realtor.com. Set it up once and you'll see these towns before anybody else does — while they're still inside your filter.

---

#7 — Killingly: $370,000, and the lowest tax bill on this list

This one is way out in the northeast corner of the state. People call that part of Connecticut the Quiet Corner, and it earns the name.

Median: $370,000. Thirty thousand from the line.

Here's why it's on the list. Sales in Killingly went up 12.6% last year. The statewide figure was around 2%. People are finding this place — and when people find a place, the prices follow. Always.

What's in Killingly

Killingly has a borough inside it — Danielson — built around the old brick textile mills along the river. There's Alexander Lake, and Old Furnace State Park, named for an old iron furnace, with rock ledges and a view out over the valley. I-395 runs right through the middle of town, which puts you under an hour to Providence and under an hour to Worcester.

Be honest: if you live in Connecticut, had you heard of Killingly before? If you don't live here, I'd bet you hadn't. Most people haven't — and that's exactly why it's still under $400,000.

Killingly has the lowest mill rate on this entire list. A typical house runs about $463 a month in taxes. Compare that to most of Hartford County and that's a real difference every single month.

The honest part

Killingly is quiet and rural, and it is not for everybody. If you need to be in Hartford every day, this is not your town. But if you work remote, or you're oriented toward Rhode Island or Massachusetts, look at it before everybody else does.

---

#6 — Bloomfield: same $370,000, but moving faster

Same median as Killingly, going up faster — so it ranks one spot closer to the line. And it's the total opposite of the Quiet Corner. Bloomfield is right on the edge of Hartford.

In 2021 Bloomfield's median was $249,000. It's up 48% in four years — about $30,000 a year, which puts roughly 12 months between Bloomfield and $400,000.

Clues, then the answer

A major health insurance company has its world headquarters here. There's a public golf course designed by Pete Dye — one of the most famous course designers in the world — and you can play it without a membership. And before the town had its current name, it was called Wintonbury.

That's Bloomfield. The insurer is Cigna, headquartered right in town. The course is Wintonbury Hills.

Where people get Bloomfield wrong

They see it sitting next to Hartford and assume it's going to feel like Hartford. It doesn't. Bloomfield has a lot of open space — Penwood State Park right on the Simsbury line, trails up on the ridge, the Pete Dye course, real employment in town.

You're about 15 minutes to downtown Hartford and about 15 minutes to Bradley Airport. If you fly a lot, that second one is a big deal.

It's also worth knowing that Bloomfield sits directly against West Hartford — you can cross the line and not realize you crossed it. West Hartford's median was around $520,000. Bloomfield's was $370,000. Same side of Hartford, minutes apart.

Now the honest part

Bloomfield's taxes are the highest on this list. Around $769 a month on the typical house.

So Bloomfield gives you a lot of house and a lot of land for the money — but you have to budget for the taxes. Don't fall in love with the house and forget the tax bill. Know the number before you go look.

---

This whole thing comes down to timing, not finding a perfect town

It's about getting into the right town while the number is still inside your budget. That's what we do every day.

We've been handling relocations into and out of Connecticut for almost 20 years, with around 140 agents across the state. If you want help working out which of these towns fits your life, your commute, and most importantly your budget, book a free Zoom or phone call. We'll look at your actual numbers and tell you where you should be looking. No pressure — just a plan.

Call or text: 203-910-2638

---

While we're on taxes: Killingly and Bloomfield are the whole lesson

Killingly and Bloomfield have exactly the same median sales price — $370,000.

Their tax bills are about $306 a month apart.

At today's rates, $306 a month in payment supports roughly $48,000 of additional home. Same house price, same state, and one town hands you nearly fifty thousand dollars of buying power the other one doesn't.

Look at the mill rate before you look at the kitchen.

---

#5 — Cromwell: up 18.5% in a single year

Cromwell did something last year no other town on this list did. The median went up 18.5% in one year. I double-checked it because it looked wrong. It wasn't.

Median now: $377,500. In 2021 it was $227,000. That's about $150,000 in four years — a 66% run.

Every summer the best golfers in the world show up here. It's a stop on the PGA Tour. It sits right on the Connecticut River, in the dead middle of the state. And if you watched my video on the towns not to overlook in 2027, this was number one.

What Cromwell really has

The Travelers Championship is played at TPC River Highlands. Even if you don't golf — and I don't — you go. The whole town turns into a party for the week, and it's one of the biggest events in Connecticut all year.

But the rest of the year, what Cromwell has is location. I-91 and Route 9. Twenty minutes to Hartford, twenty to Middletown, thirty to New Haven. You can work just about anywhere in central Connecticut and live here.

The runway

At Cromwell's four-year average pace, $22,500 is about seven months. But here's the sharper way to look at it: if Cromwell does even a third of what it did last year, it's already over $400,000. A third of 18.5% is 6.2%, and 6.2% on $377,500 is $400,800.

If you want Cromwell under $400,000, you are running out of runway.

---

The $400,000 filter mistake I see constantly

Somebody sets their search max at exactly $400,000. They find a house listed at $390,000. They figure they've got $10,000 of room — and they lose it to a buyer who paid $405,000.

In most of these towns sellers have been getting well above asking. So that house listed at $390,000 goes for $401,000, $403,000, maybe $410,000. You were over before you started.

If $400,000 is truly your maximum, set your search filter lower. Try $385,000. Then when you find the one you love, you have room to compete — because if it's listed at $385,000, you can offer $400,000 and still be inside your number.

That one change will save you a lot of heartbreak. Go to searchallcthomes.com, set your max at $385,000 in any of these towns, and see what's actually there. It takes two minutes.

---

#4 — Ansonia: $380,000, and the pause is your window

This one isn't far from where we film, in Prospect. And it's a town people skipped for far too long.

Median: $380,000 — about $20,000 from the line. But in 2021 it was $255,000. That's a $125,000 increase in four years, a 49% run.

The clues

This town is named after a man named Anson. It was built on brass and copper — so much copper they called it the Copper City. A famous clock company got its start here, and old clocks with this town's name on the face are still sitting on mantels all over the country. And it's tiny: about six square miles, one of the smallest towns in Connecticut.

That's Ansonia — named for Anson Phelps, the businessman who built it. The Ansonia Clock Company started right here.

You can still see that industrial history all through the Valley: the old Victorians, the brick buildings along the Naugatuck River. There's a station on the Metro-North Waterbury branch line, Route 8 puts Waterbury about 20 minutes north, the Merritt Parkway is roughly 15 minutes south, and the Ansonia Nature Center sits up on the hill with trails and a pond. Great spot for a fall afternoon.

At a 28.55 mill rate, the typical house there runs about $633 a month in taxes.

Here's the interesting part about Ansonia

Last year it only went up 4.1% — one of the slowest on this list. So why is it here?

Because over four years it averaged better than 10% a year. Last year was a pause, not a stop. And towns that pause tend to catch up.

That pause is the best thing on this page for a buyer. A town that's been moving fast and finally takes a breath has a little more inventory than its neighbors do. That window does not stay open long.

---

#3 — Coventry: a lake town under $400,000

We're out east in Tolland County now. Median: $388,000 — twelve thousand from the line.

The clues

This is the hometown of one of the most famous Americans of the Revolutionary War — a schoolteacher who became a spy. You know his last words: "I only regret that I have but one life to lose for my country." His childhood home is still standing here, and there's a farmers market on the grounds every Sunday.

And there's a lake right in the middle of town. Locals still call it by its old name — the Wangumbaug.

This is Coventry, birthplace of Nathan Hale.

A lake town for under $400,000 in Connecticut is not going to last

You're about 10 minutes to UConn in Storrs and 25 to 30 minutes to Hartford. I-384 ends just west of town in Bolton, which gets you onto the highway quickly.

In the summer people are out on Coventry Lake swimming and fishing — it's about 374 acres, and Patriots Park sits right on the water and connects into the village greenway, so you can walk from the beach to dinner. On a Connecticut lake, that is genuinely unusual.

In the fall, the Nathan Hale Homestead is about as New England as it gets — stone walls, the old farmhouse, the back roads.

The catch

At the end of last year there were only 15 homes for sale in all of Coventry, and they were going under contract in about two weeks.

Coventry's taxes are on the low end of this list — around $538 a month on the typical house. That's a good number for a lake town.

One thing to know: Coventry recently went through a revaluation, and the mill rate dropped from 33.31 to 23.76. That's not a tax cut. Assessments were reset upward at the same time, which is why the rate came down. The dollar figure above is what matters, not the rate by itself.

At Coventry's four-year average pace, $12,000 is about five months.

If you like the idea of having a lake in your town, Coventry is the one I'd look at this winter — not in the spring.

---

Why I keep saying winter

Fewer people are out looking. Sellers who list in November, December and January generally have more motivation. You're not standing in a line of fifteen people at an open house throwing offers at the same listing.

The next few months are when buyers have the most leverage. Get out there.

---

#2 — New Hartford: $388,250, and the steadiest town here

Basically tied with Coventry on price — $388,250 — but on the other side of Hartford, up in the hills of the northwest.

The clues

This town has its own ski mountain, right in town — night skiing, lessons, the whole operation. In the summer people float down the river on inner tubes through a stretch with one of the best names in the state: Satan's Kingdom. And there's a large reservoir here that's part of Greater Hartford's drinking water supply.

This is New Hartford. The mountain is Ski Sundown. The river is the Farmington. Route 44 runs through it.

My aunt and uncle live right next door in Barkhamsted, so I'm up that way quite a bit. You're about half an hour to Hartford, and it feels a lot further out than it is.

At 26.87, the typical house runs about $609 a month in taxes.

Why it's on the list when it's the slowest-growing town here

New Hartford has not exploded like Cromwell. Over the last four years it's the slowest mover on this entire list.

So why is it here? Because it only needs about 3%. It's that close. And sellers in New Hartford have been getting about 104% of asking — the highest figure on this list. That tells you buyers are competing hard for the little that's available.

Coventry or New Hartford — same price, different lives

If you want water and you want to buy before the next jump, it's Coventry. If you want hills and woods in a town that isn't going to swing on you, it's New Hartford. Neither is wrong — just know which one is more you before you start touring.

---

One I left off, and why

Lisbon, in New London County. Median $397,000 — just $3,000 from the line, closer than anything else here.

But Lisbon only sold 45 homes all year. With that few sales, a couple of large transactions move the median far too much to trust it. Seventy sales minimum, or it's off the list.

That's how you know these eight are real.

---

#1 — Wallingford: $5,000 away

The last clues: this town has a station on the Hartford Line, so you can get from New Haven to Hartford without touching a highway. It runs its own electric company. There's a vineyard up on the ridge with views for miles, a theater where big-name concerts come through all year, and it sits right in the middle of the state, halfway between New Haven and Hartford.

This is Wallingford. Median sales price last year: $395,000.

Five thousand dollars from $400,000.

It only needs 1% more

Wallingford went up more than 10% last year. It needs 1.27% to cross. At last year's pace that's about six weeks. At its four-year average pace it's about two months.

By the time you read this, it may already be over.

What you get

The vineyard is Gouveia Vineyards, up on the ridge. The theater is the Oakdale. There's a real downtown on Center Street, and every fall the whole town turns out for Celebrate Wallingford, the big street festival.

In 2021 Wallingford's median was $279,900. It's up about 41% in four years — and it's the biggest town on this list with the most sales, which means it's also the one with real inventory to look at.

And after Wallingford's most recent revaluation, taxes on the typical house run around $556 a month. For a train town in the dead center of the state, that is hard to beat. The town owning its own electric utility doesn't hurt either.

This is the one I'd be most worried about losing if I were you.

---

What if a town crosses $400,000 before you get there?

It's not gone. It just means you're shopping below the middle of that town — so you'll have a smaller selection. Maybe you end up in a condo. Maybe the house you can afford needs a kitchen.

That's the trade-off. It's not a dead end. But it's a different search than the one you'd have had six months earlier, and that's the whole point of this list.

---

All eight, side by side

Tax estimated as median sale price × 0.70 assessment ratio × (mill rate ÷ 1,000). These are estimates on the median house, not a quote on any specific property — your actual bill depends on that home's assessed value. Coventry's rate reflects a recent revaluation, so its lower rate is not a tax cut.

Two things that table makes obvious

Killingly and Bloomfield have the identical median and a $306-a-month difference in taxes. Same price, same state, nearly $48,000 of buying power between them. That's the single best argument on this page for checking the mill rate before anything else.

And look at the two cheapest towns versus the two closest to crossing. Rocky Hill and Killingly are the furthest from $400,000 — and Rocky Hill has 14 houses for sale while Killingly sits at the bottom of the tax column. Cheapest and most available are not the same thing. Rocky Hill is cheap and empty, which is exactly the combination that closes a window fast.

---

Heads up: mill rates just changed for FY2027

The rates in the table above are the FY2026 rates, which is the year that matches these sale prices. New rates are now out, and most of these towns moved. Here's the update on the same medians:

Two things worth noting. Bloomfield is the only one that went down — and it's still the highest on the list. And the Killingly-to-Bloomfield gap narrowed from $306 a month to about $271, which is still roughly $43,000 of buying power between two towns with the same median price.

This is why I tell people to check the current rate rather than one they read somewhere. Mill rates get set every year, and a number from last spring can be off by thirty dollars a month before you've looked at a single house.

---

So which town is $5,000 from leaving your search for good?

We're one of the most trusted relocation teams in Connecticut, and we've got your back coming into the state or heading out of it.

If you want help figuring out which of these eight fits your commute, your life, and your actual budget — before the filter closes on one of them — reach out.

Call or text: 203-910-2638 Email: Dave@davejonesrealty.com Search every home in Connecticut: www.searchallcthomes.com

---

Market data reflects the most recent full year of closed sales reported through SmartMLS and is subject to revision; medians move and the figures here will age. Property tax figures are estimates calculated on each town's median sale price using the 70% assessment ratio and the stated mill rate — they are not a quote on any individual property, and towns that have recently revalued will show a lower mill rate without a corresponding drop in the actual bill. Any statement about how long a town has before it crosses $400,000 is a straight-line projection from past sales data, not a forecast, and nothing here is investment advice. For school information, see GreatSchools.org and contact the district directly. For public safety information, contact the local police department and review the state's published data yourself. Always conduct independent due diligence on any town and any property before buying.

Dave Jones Realty LLC | Serving New Haven, Hartford, and Litchfield Counties