
So you're thinking of moving to the great state of Connecticut.
I'm Dave Jones with Dave Jones Realty. Almost everybody who moves here looks at the same handful of towns — and while they're all fighting over those, there are eight towns where values are climbing faster than the rest of the state and almost nobody is talking about them.
The last one on this list is $351,000, and what's happening there is the difference maker in this whole thing.
First, how I ranked these — because the method is the point
I am not ranking these on price. Here's why that matters.
Take Harwinton, the first town on this list. The typical house sold there this year for $494,000. Last year that number was $425,000. So it looks like the town jumped 16%.
It didn't. Bigger houses sold this year.
If ten big houses sell in a town this year and ten small ones sold last year, the typical price leaps and somebody on the internet says that town is on fire. Nothing happened. Those were just bigger houses.
Price per square foot takes that trick away. So that's what I used.
Every house sold January 1st through October 28th. No condos. Only towns with enough normal activity that a normal person can actually buy there. And none of the towns from my first two "don't overlook" videos are on this list.
Across Connecticut, price per square foot is up about 5%. Every town here beat that.
This is the single most useful thing in this article, and you can do it yourself on any house. Take the price a house actually sold for — not the asking price — and divide by the square footage. Do that for three or four sold houses on the same street. Now you know what that part of town really costs, and whether the house you're looking at is on the high side or the low side. It takes five minutes and almost nobody does it. Most people look at the asking price and the photos, make a decision, and pay for it for thirty years.
#8 — Harwinton: three times the state's land
Up the hill in Litchfield County, right between Torrington and Burlington. It has a country fair every year that people drive in from all over.
And back in 1821 a boy was born here who grew up to help build the Central Pacific Railroad — Collis Huntington. He started out peddling goods and ended up helping connect the whole country by rail.
I know this area well. We spend a lot of time up at Bantam in the summer, and it's not far from there.
What you get out here is land
The typical house that sold this year sits on 1.38 acres. Statewide, the average is 0.46 of an acre.
That's three times the land.
The typical Harwinton house sold for $494,000. And remember — the 16% headline is a mirage. The real number is price per square foot, and that's up 7.2%.
Not crazy. But look at what else moved. Houses went from sitting 17 days last year to 9 days this year. And the share going over asking went from 31% to 54%.
People are finding it.
Harwinton just went through a revaluation and the mill rate landed at 23.00. On that house the estimated tax is about $663 a month. (As always with a revaluation: the rate came down because assessments went up. It isn't a tax cut.)
It's a small town — only 37 homes sold so far this year. So when something good comes up, you cannot sleep on it.
If there's one town you keep coming back to, text it to me. I'll tell you the town next door you're probably overlooking — or whether the one you're looking at is actually the right one.
#7 — Bloomfield: the same house as West Hartford for $165,000 less
This town used to have a different name. Back in the 1700s, people out here had to travel to three different towns for church. So they formed their own parish and mashed the three names together — Windsor, Farmington and Simsbury — into Wintonbury. It eventually got renamed, but you'll still see the old name around town.
And if you want a view, there's a state park on the ridge right in town where you can walk up to a pond at the top and look out over the whole valley.
The numbers
The typical house sold for $400,000, and for that you get 1,791 square feet.
That's more space than the typical house in Connecticut — and the typical house in Connecticut costs $485,000.
So you're getting more house for $85,000 less. That's the entire reason this town is on the list.
Price per square foot is up 7.4% — and the secret is getting out. 70% of homes sold over asking, and when they go over, they typically go over by $25,000.
Put that in your budget before you fall in love. The list price is the starting price.
Now look at the town right next door
Everybody knows West Hartford. Great town, great restaurants, great bars.
| Bloomfield | West Hartford | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical sale price | $400,000 | $565,158 |
| Square feet | 1,791 | 1,776 |
| Mill rate | 35.64 | 44.78 |
| Est. monthly tax | ~$832 | ~$1,476 |
Essentially the same size house for $165,000 less — and $644 a month less in tax.
That's what I mean by overlooked. It's one town away, and almost nobody crosses the border.
But here's the part you have to watch
On a $400,000 Bloomfield house, the estimated tax is $832 a month at the town's rate. And Bloomfield has fire districts on top of that — so depending on the street, it's more like $875 to $904.
Most people moving here have never heard of a fire district. You look up the town's mill rate online, you think you know the number, and then the bill comes.
Text me the address of any house you're looking at and I'll tell you what the bill is really going to be — before you make an offer, not after. That's one of the things we do for clients.
(One nice footnote: I had Bloomfield on an earlier list as a town about to cross $400,000, back when it was at $370,000. It just crossed. That's how fast this moves.)
#6 — Litchfield: the town people cross off their list by mistake
America's first law school started here, in a little building behind a house on South Street. Aaron Burr studied there. Harriet Beecher Stowe was born here. And the center of town looks like Norman Rockwell painted it — white houses, big trees, and a long green running through the middle of everything.
You can walk from the green, get coffee at Espresso 59, have dinner at West Street Grill or Marketplace Tavern, stop into our office — and never get back in your car.
I'm biased, and I'll tell you why: we just opened our office here in the Marketplace building, right across from the green.
"Is Litchfield really overlooked?"
Most people moving to Connecticut assume they can't afford it. That's the overlooking.
The typical house sold this year at $552,000, with over an acre of land, and price per square foot is up 7.8%.
Now look at this. The mill rate is 20.00. So that $552,000 house carries an estimated tax bill of about $645 a month. (Inside the borough, which has its own additional rate, figure closer to $700.)
That is less than you'd pay on a $400,000 house in the town I just showed you.
Read that again. A $552,000 house on an acre in Litchfield costs less to carry in tax than a $400,000 house in Bloomfield. That's the mill rate doing more work than the price.
And here's the best part
Litchfield is one of the few towns in this article where you won't get run over.
Only 45% of houses went over asking. There are 27 for sale right now — more than five months of supply at the current pace.
In most of the state you get a weekend to decide. Here you can actually think. That means you can ask for an inspection. You can ask for repairs if something turns up. In a lot of the towns in this article, you'd get laughed at.
So when you're making a list of towns you can't afford — go check that list again. A lot of people cross out towns they shouldn't have, because they never factored in the tax bill.
This is where I'd want to help
A lot of you are reading this with a map open, trying to work out where you actually belong.
Book a free Zoom relocation call. We're low stress — even if you're not moving until next year. Tell us your budget, where you'll be working, how much house you need, what you want the yard to look like.
We'll go through real towns and real numbers, tax bills included, so you pick the right town the first time.
Call or text: 203-910-2638
#5 — Windsor Locks: the town that just got a $121 million train station
Back in 1829, boats on the Connecticut River had a problem. There was a stretch of rapids they couldn't get through, so they dug a canal around it with locks to raise and lower the boats. That's where the town got its name. You can still walk or bike the canal today.
There's also a big air museum here with military planes in it, right on the edge of the state's largest airport.
But the reason this town is on the list isn't from 1829
On October 18th, a brand new $121 million train station opened right in the middle of town.
Hartford Line and Amtrak service — around 31 trains every weekday. And there's a bus from the station to Bradley Airport roughly every 20 minutes on weekdays.
Think about what that combination is. A train that runs Hartford to New Haven, and you can be at the airport in minutes.
The numbers
Typical house: $350,000. Price per square foot up 8.3%.
And you want to know how tight it is? 82% of homes sold over asking this year.
Eighty-two percent. And fewer houses are selling — 76 so far this year against 97 at this point last year. That's not because nobody wants them. It's because there aren't any for sale.
Keep in mind these are smaller houses — about 1,270 square feet on 0.34 of an acre, mostly built in the '50s. The estimated tax is about $490 a month, one of the lowest here.
This was already a hard town to buy in. Now it has a train station. Do the math.
And here's how I'd think about that train
Don't take anybody's word for it, including mine. Get on it.
Pick a weekday morning and ride it to wherever you'll be working. See how long it actually takes door to door.
A train station is only worth paying for if you're going to use it.
#4 — East Granby: an underground prison and seven houses for sale
This is my favorite story on the list.
In the early 1700s they opened the first chartered copper mine in the country here. It didn't work out. So what do you do with a big wet hole in the side of a mountain?
In 1773, Connecticut turned it into a state prison. They kept prisoners underground, down in the mine. During the Revolution they put loyalists down there — and you can still go see what's left of it.
That's Old New-Gate Prison, and the town is East Granby.
So why is a town with an underground prison on this list?
Because it's about 10 minutes from Bradley Airport, it's got ridgeline hiking right out the back door, and for the money you get a real house.
The typical house sold for $485,000 — that's 1,965 square feet on just over an acre. Price per square foot is up 8.9%.
And this is the smallest market on the list. Only 40 houses sold all year. There are seven for sale right now.
Seven.
The typical house was gone in six days, and when they go, they go over asking by an average of $31,555.
You can't shop a town like this the way you shop a big one
There's no scrolling through 50 listings and picking your favorite. You're going to get one shot, maybe two, in an entire spring.
So know ahead of time what you'd pay. Get the pre-approval done before you ever drive up there. Walk the town. Learn the streets you'd want. So when that one house comes up on a Tuesday, you're not starting from zero — your offer's in by Tuesday night.
The estimated tax is about $863 a month. Not the lowest here, but you're getting an acre and you're ten minutes from a flight to anywhere.
Why you keep missing towns like this
When you start looking online, the same names come up over and over. That's because that's where everybody is clicking. So those towns get more clicks, more people show up at the open house, and the prices go up.
And the town one exit over never came up at all.
You have to go looking for it.
#3 — Plainville: fewer houses, higher prices, same town
You've driven past this one if you've ever been on I-84 heading to Bristol. It sits in the notch where I-84 and Route 72 come together.
The old Farmington Canal came straight through here in the 1800s, and you can still ride your bike along that route. There's a big rock formation people climb for a look over the whole valley. And you're next door to New Britain, Bristol, Farmington and Southington — so you can be anywhere in central Connecticut in about 15 minutes.
The numbers, and why it's back
The typical house costs $365,000. Price per square foot is up 9%. And this is the fastest town on the list — the typical house was gone in seven days, with 79% selling over asking.
If you've been following along you already know Plainville. But look at why it's back on a list like this.
Last year at this point, 129 houses had sold. This year, 107. Sales are down 17% — and price per square foot is still up 9%.
Fewer houses are coming up, and each one costs more.
That's what it looks like when people have already decided where they want to live and they aren't leaving.
And one more thing: J. Timothy's has some of the best wings in the state. Every Super Bowl weekend they move 24,000 pounds of them. If you're out looking at houses in the area, go get some.
These are smaller houses — about 1,304 square feet on 0.27 of an acre. The estimated tax is about $732 a month.
Here's where most people get this wrong
They see $365,000, they offer $365,000, and they lose. Over and over.
The typical overbid here is $20,000.
So shop below what you can actually afford. If you're maxing out at $400,000, don't look at $400,000 houses. Look at $375,000 to $380,000. That one change will save you a lot of heartbreak.
And here's why so few houses come up
A lot of the people already living there are sitting on a mortgage rate they will never see again. They are not leaving.
So you have more buyers showing up and fewer houses to buy — and that does not get fixed next year because you waited.
#2 — Clinton: the shoreline town people skip for its neighbors
The very first classes of what became Yale University were held right here. Back in 1701 the first rector taught his students in his own house, in what is now this town on the shoreline. They moved the whole thing to New Haven later.
This town let Yale get away.
Now you've got a town beach, a marina, outlet stores right off I-95, and a Shore Line East train station. And Hammonasset — the biggest beach in the state — is right next door.
Everybody overlooks Clinton because they're looking at Madison and Guilford
Those are great towns. But the typical house in Madison sold for $795,000. In Clinton it's $527,800.
And price per square foot in Clinton is up 14.1% — almost three times the state average.
The typical house sits on 0.6 of an acre, on the shoreline, for $527,800.
Now let me be straight with you: these are not big houses. About 1,485 square feet. And the estimated tax bill is $959 a month — plus a bit more if you're in one of the beach associations, which levy their own rate.
So it's not cheap to own. But if you want salt air and a train and you've been told you need $800,000 to get it — you've been told wrong.
One thing before you buy anywhere on the shoreline
Look up the flood map. FEMA has them online, free, and it takes two minutes.
A house that's a short walk from the beach can come with a flood insurance bill that changes your entire budget. Ask your insurance agent for a real quote before you make an offer, not after.
That's not a reason to stay away from the water. It's a reason to know what you're buying.
#1 — East Windsor: the fastest real growth in the state, at $351,000
In 1636, the man who founded Springfield, Massachusetts built a warehouse on the Connecticut River at the exact spot where the big boats couldn't go any further. That's how Warehouse Point got its name.
And in 1818, a man digging a well here hit some bones. Nobody knew it for years, but those were among the very first dinosaur bones ever found in America.
Now look at what's happening today
The typical house went from $310,000 last year to $351,000 this year. Price per square foot is up 14.4% — the most of any town on this list, nearly three times the state. And sales are up 19%.
Sales up and prices up is a different signal than prices up alone. In Plainville, prices rose while sales fell — that's scarcity. Here, more people are buying and paying more. That's demand arriving.
You get about 1,578 square feet on 0.63 of an acre, and you're just 10 minutes from Bradley Airport.
The estimated tax bill is $510 a month at the town rate — or about $542 to $553 if you're in one of the fire districts. Ask which one before you offer.
The number one town you should not overlook this year is East Windsor.
All eight, side by side
| # | Town | County | Typical house | Price/sq ft | Over asking | Mill rate | Est. tax/mo |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Harwinton | Litchfield | $494,000 | +7.2% | 54% (was 31%) | 23.00 | ~$663 |
| 7 | Bloomfield | Hartford | $400,000 | +7.4% | 70% | 35.64 + district | ~$832–904 |
| 6 | Litchfield | Litchfield | $552,000 | +7.8% | 45% | 20.00 + borough | ~$645–700 |
| 5 | Windsor Locks | Hartford | $350,000 | +8.3% | 82% | 23.99 | ~$490 |
| 4 | East Granby | Hartford | $485,000 | +8.9% | — | ~30.50 | ~$863 |
| 3 | Plainville | Hartford | $365,000 | +9.0% | 79% | 34.36 | ~$732 |
| 2 | Clinton | Middlesex | $527,800 | +14.1% | — | 31.14 + beach assoc. | ~$959 |
| 1 | East Windsor | Hartford | $351,000 | +14.4% | — | 24.89 + district | ~$510–553 |
| — | Connecticut | — | $485,000 | +5% | 61% | — | — |
Based on closed single-family sales from January 1 through October 28; condominiums excluded. Taxes estimated as typical sale price × 0.70 assessment ratio × (mill rate ÷ 1,000). Bloomfield, Litchfield borough, Clinton's beach associations and East Windsor all levy additional district rates on top of the town rate — the ranges reflect them. East Granby's rate is derived from the stated monthly figure and should be confirmed. Harwinton's 23.00 follows a revaluation, so its lower rate reflects reassessed values, not a tax cut.
Three things this table makes obvious
Litchfield breaks the rule everyone assumes. It has the second-highest price on the page and the second-lowest tax bill. A $552,000 house there carries less tax than a $400,000 house in Bloomfield. If you've been crossing Litchfield off because of the sticker price, you crossed off the wrong thing.
The two fastest-growing towns are also two of the three cheapest. Clinton and East Windsor are up 14.1% and 14.4% per square foot — and East Windsor costs $351,000. Fast growth and a low entry price usually don't travel together. When they do, that's the signal.
And look at the over-asking column against the price-per-square-foot column. Windsor Locks is at 82% over asking with 8.3% growth. Litchfield is at 45% with 7.8%. Nearly the same appreciation — and completely different experiences trying to buy. One of those you win by being fastest. The other you win by being thorough.
So which one is yours?
If there's one town you keep circling back to, text it to me. I'll tell you what's really happening there — and the town next door you haven't considered.
And if you want me to pull the real sold numbers for a town so you can run the price-per-square-foot math yourself, just ask.
We're one of the most trusted relocation teams in Connecticut, and we've got your back whether you're coming into the state or heading out of it.
Call or text: 203-910-2638 Email: Dave@davejonesrealty.com Search every home in Connecticut: www.searchallcthomes.com
Market data reflects closed single-family sales reported through SmartMLS from January 1 through October 28; condominiums are excluded, towns below a normal level of sales activity were not ranked, and these figures will age. Rankings use median price per square foot rather than median sale price, because a change in the mix of houses sold can move a median price without the market moving at all. Property tax figures are estimates calculated as typical sale price × 0.70 assessment ratio × (mill rate ÷ 1,000); they are not a quote on any individual property, and your actual Connecticut bill depends on that home's assessed value from the town's most recent revaluation and on which taxing district it sits in. Bloomfield, East Windsor and many other municipalities levy separate fire district rates, Litchfield has a borough rate, and Clinton has beach associations with their own levies — these do not appear on most listing sites, so always confirm the district for a specific property. Connecticut municipalities must revalue at least every five years, and a lower mill rate following a revaluation is not a tax cut. Flood zone status materially affects the cost of owning near the shoreline; consult FEMA's flood maps and obtain an actual insurance quote before making an offer. Statements about past price movement are history, not a forecast, and nothing here is investment, tax or insurance advice. For school information, see GreatSchools.org and contact the district directly. For public safety information, contact the local police department and review the state's published data yourself. Always conduct independent due diligence on any town and any property before buying.
Dave Jones Realty LLC | Serving Connecticut from offices in Prospect, Watertown, Middletown, and Litchfield