I'm Dave Jones with Dave Jones Realty, and home sales across Connecticut are down 2% this year.
So I went through every house sale in the state to find the towns going the other way.
These ten towns are up as much as 34% — and the town at the top has something going for it that almost never happens.
How this list works, so you know I'm not making it up
I took every single house that sold in Connecticut from January through October. No condos, just houses. Then I compared the exact same dates from last year.
And I threw out the tiny towns — if a town sells five houses one year and ten the next, that's not a trend. I stayed in the part of the state I know best, and I left out the towns I've already featured on these lists. (Two exceptions I'll flag as we go, because what happened in them is the story.)
And here's why I rank on sales, not price
Sales go first. Prices go second.
When more people start buying in a town, the prices show up afterward. That's the whole reason I watch this number — it's the earlier signal.
But rising sales can mean three different things
It can mean more people want to live there. It can mean more people decided to sell. Or it can mean a builder just finished a bunch of houses.
So you can't look at the sales number and call it a day. Here's how to tell the difference:
- Sales up and houses selling faster → buyers are piling in.
- Sales up and houses sitting longer → more sellers showed up. That's a window for you.
I'll point out which is which as we go.
If you've got a budget and no idea which town fits it, text me. I'll tell you the two towns I'd look at first. That's it.
#10 — Cheshire: the most expensive town here, and worth understanding why
This town calls itself the bedding plant capital of Connecticut. That's a real thing — drive through in May and you'll see why.
It also had a lot of mining back in the 1800s, digging barite out of the ground. And the old Farmington Canal ran straight through the middle of it. There's a restored canal lock you can go see, and the old towpath is now one of the best bike trails in Connecticut.
The numbers
Sales are up 7.5% — 200 so far this year, against 186 last year. The typical house sold for $595,000, which gets you about 2,000 square feet on 0.76 of an acre.
This is the most expensive town on the list, and it's right at the top of what a lot of you are looking to spend.
And it moves fast. The typical house was gone in eight days, 70% went over asking, and the typical overbid was $35,000.
So that $595,000 house isn't really $595,000.
Now here's why people pay it
Look next door at Hamden. The typical house there sold for $393,500 — more than $200,000 cheaper. So you'd think Hamden is obviously the smarter move.
But Hamden's mill rate is 51.88.
| Cheshire | Hamden | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical sale price | $595,000 | $393,500 |
| Mill rate | 29.74 | 51.88 |
| Est. annual tax | ~$12,387 | ~$14,290 |
| Est. monthly tax | ~$1,032 | ~$1,191 |
The Cheshire house costs $201,500 more — and the tax bill is $159 a month lower.
Bigger house, more land, and you pay less every month to own it.
That is why you cannot shop by price alone in Connecticut.
#9 — Enfield: where the fire districts get people
In 1741 a preacher named Jonathan Edwards came to this town and delivered one of the most famous sermons in American history — "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God." They say people were crying out in the pews so loudly he had to stop.
Later on, this town made gunpowder. The Hazard Powder Company turned out an enormous amount of the powder used in the Civil War. There was a Shaker community here too.
And for decades, if you stepped on a little plastic brick in the dark anywhere in North America, the company that made it was headquartered right here. That's Enfield, longtime U.S. home of LEGO.
The numbers
Sales are up 7.6%, and there are a lot of them — 338 houses sold this year, with only 41 currently for sale.
The typical house is $350,000. 75% sold over asking. The typical house was gone in seven days.
Now pay attention to the tax, because this is where Enfield gets people
At the town rate, that $350,000 house is about $643 a month.
But Enfield has five separate fire districts, plus a tax district. Depending on which one a house sits in, the real number is more like $707 to $762 a month.
Nobody tells you that. The number on the internet is not always the number.
Here's what that looks like laid out:
| Rate | Est. monthly | |
|---|---|---|
| Town rate only | 31.50 | ~$643 |
| With a fire district | ~34.6 to ~37.3 | ~$707–762 |
You have to do the due diligence.
And you're right on the Massachusetts line — Springfield is a short run up I-91, Hartford a short run down. A lot of people land here because one person has work in one direction and somebody else has work in the other.
#8 — Wolcott: a good price on the house, a big number on the tax bill
A man was born in this town in 1799, the son of a farmer who never had any money. He taught himself just about everything, walked all over the South selling goods out of a backpack, and became a famous teacher and philosopher.
But most people know him because of his daughter — Louisa May Alcott, who wrote Little Women. Her father, Amos Bronson Alcott, came right from this town.
Wolcott is right in our backyard. I've lived in Prospect for over 50 years, and Wolcott is just up the road.
The numbers
Sales are up 8.1%. Typical price $410,000. And price per square foot is up 11.9% — more than double what's happening statewide.
So sales and values are both moving at the same time. That's a town people have figured out.
And it makes sense. You're up on the hill, it's quiet, and you can reach Waterbury, Bristol or Southington in about 15 minutes.
The catch — and there's always a catch
The mill rate is 35.93.
You'll notice this on a lot of the towns here: the house prices are a little better because the taxes are a little higher. That's the trade.
On the typical house, taxes run about $859 a month. A good price on the house, a big number on the tax bill.
#7 — Ansonia: the best tax argument on this entire page
This town got started because a copper merchant from New York wanted to build a factory on the Naugatuck River. His name was Anson Phelps. They named the place after him, and for a long time everybody called it the Copper City. Brass, copper, clocks — you name it, they made it here.
And now it has a Metro-North station and Route 8 running right through it — which puts you on the train without paying what you'd pay in Fairfield County.
The numbers
Sales are up 8.2%, and the typical house sold for $385,000 — basically what it was last year.
So this is not a town that's running away from you. That's what I like about it. More people are buying and the price hasn't taken off yet.
Mostly older homes on smaller lots, about 0.23 of an acre on average. The estimated tax is $641 a month.
If your budget is under $400,000 and you want the train, Ansonia belongs on your list.
And here's something else to think about
A few miles down the road in Shelton, the typical home sold for $592,500. Shelton's a great town with one of the lowest mill rates around — 18.82 — and the estimated tax there is about $650 a month.
| Ansonia | Shelton | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical sale price | $385,000 | $592,500 |
| Mill rate | 28.55 | 18.82 |
| Est. monthly tax | ~$641 | ~$650 |
Look at that again. Essentially the same tax bill — on a house that costs $207,500 less.
That is the single clearest illustration on this page of what the mill rate actually does. Shelton's rate is one of the lowest in the state, and it still can't overcome a house that costs two hundred grand more. The rate matters enormously — right up until the price gap gets big enough to swamp it.
Before you start driving around
If you're seriously thinking about moving here, do one thing before you tour a single town — before you even set up your Zillow search. Book a free call with me.
Zoom, phone, however you want. We'll talk about where you'll be working, what you like to do outside of work, what actually matters to you. And we'll go through real numbers, tax bills included, so you're ready when you start looking.
Call or text: 203-910-2638
#6 — New Milford: room to negotiate, which is rare on this list
The biggest lake in Connecticut touches one of this town's borders. It's man-made, and the people here will correct you if you forget that.
As a young man, Roger Sherman lived here, working as a shoemaker and a surveyor — long before he went on to sign both the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.
There's a long green right in the center of town, with shops and restaurants along Bank Street. And by land area, this is the biggest town in the state.
The numbers
Sales are up 9.7%, with 226 houses sold so far. Typical price $549,450 — and for that you get a full acre.
Now here's what I want you to notice. It takes a while to sell here. The typical house took 28 days, and only 44% went over asking.
So you have a little room to negotiate. In a lot of this article, you won't.
The estimated tax is about $992 a month, and that puts you right around Candlewood Lake.
One thing to ask about: some of the lake communities have their own tax district on top of the town rate. When you see a house at or near the water, ask — they can add $100 a month or more, depending on what amenities are included.
#5 — Stratford: I'm not changing my answer, but look what the market did
Igor Sikorsky came over from Russia and ended up building helicopters here — and they've been at it for almost a hundred years.
This town also built a big Shakespeare theater right on the river, meant to rival the one in England. Katharine Hepburn acted on that stage. And there's a Metro-North station, a beach on the Sound, and both I-95 and the Merritt Parkway running through it. (I'm fairly sure I've been stuck in traffic on both.)
Some of you are going to pipe up, because I put this town on a "where not to buy" list
I did. And the tax bill is still a real thing.
The typical house is $492,500, and at a 40.20 mill rate the estimated tax is $1,155 a month.
But here's what happened. Sales are up 14.9% — 363 homes so far this year, up from 316.
People looked at the tax bill, looked at the train, looked at what a house costs a few towns over, and bought here anyway.
I'm not changing my answer. The tax bill is the tax bill. But the market is telling you that for a lot of people, the access is worth it. You just have to know what you're signing up for before you sign.
And the pace has changed significantly
The typical home took 24 days this year. Last year it was 10.
That's more sellers in the mix. So if you can stomach the tax, Stratford gives you more room to negotiate than it did twelve months ago. That's a real shift, and it's the kind of thing that doesn't show up in a price.
From here on, the numbers get a lot bigger
Every town so far is up somewhere between 7 and 15%. The top three are up 20%, 30% and 34%.
And the number one town is doing something that almost never happens: a lot more people are buying, and the price has not moved.
#4 — Westbrook: the shoreline town with a headline that lies
A man named David Bushnell was born here in 1740. He went off to Yale and built the first submarine ever used in combat — a little one-man wooden thing shaped like a turtle. They sent it into New York Harbor during the Revolution to sink a British warship.
It didn't work. But think about that: a submarine, in 1776, built by a guy from this little town. There's a replica in the town hall today.
It's got beaches, a marina, a Shore Line East station, and a stretch of Route 1 that feels like you're on vacation somewhere. This town — one of my favorites — is Westbrook.
Now here's the part where the headline lies
Sales are up 15.1%. Typical price $575,000 — down from $675,000 last year.
Don't get excited. Smaller houses sold this year. Price per square foot actually went up.
That's the trick I keep warning you about. If you just read the typical price, you'd think the place went on sale. It did not. People are buying smaller houses at the same price per foot.
The real numbers
The mill rate is 22.50, so on a $575,000 house the estimated tax is about $755 a month — plus a bit more in the beach associations, which levy their own rate.
For the shoreline, $755 is a real number.
The houses are small — about 1,560 square feet on 0.38 of an acre — but you can walk to the water in a lot of this town. And when houses sell over asking here, the typical overbid is $37,000. People are paying for it.
Next door in Old Saybrook, the typical house sold for $748,000. Westbrook is $173,000 less for the same water.
If you're shopping the shoreline, look at this town before you decide you can't afford it.
And one thing about any house near the beach
Look up the flood maps before you write an offer, and get a real insurance quote. We have terrific people right in this office — ask me and I'll send you their contact information.
A house that looks like a deal can come with a bill that changes your whole budget. Don't get surprised.
#3 — Bethany: an airport, a soccer field, and $210,000 off the town next door
Up in the hills between New Haven and Waterbury. And here's something you'd never guess: this town had a real airport.
It started in 1920 when a small plane put down in a flat field north of the center, and in 1922 Harris Whittemore Jr. of Naugatuck bought the land and built an airfield — one of the earliest private airports in New England. (Same Whittemore family that paid for those beautiful McKim, Mead & White buildings around the Naugatuck green, if you saw that video.)
It became a stop for airmail planes running between New York and Boston. And in 1930, a plane called the K of New Haven took off from here attempting the first nonstop flight from North America to South America — bound for Buenos Aires.
It ran low on fuel in heavy fog over Georgia. All three crew members bailed out by parachute and survived.
The airport closed in 1965. Today those old runways are soccer fields and walking trails.
The numbers
Sales are up 20% — only 48 houses sold so far this year, but it was 40 at this point last year. The typical house sold for $570,000 on 1.665 acres.
That's a lot of house and a lot of land. And you're 20 minutes to downtown New Haven — the best pizza in the country, the birthplace of the hamburger, Yale, and everything that comes with it.
Now look at the town right next door
| Bethany | Woodbridge | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical sale price | $570,000 | $780,000 |
| Land | ~1.665 ac | about the same |
| Est. monthly tax | ~$969 | ~$1,484 |
Bethany costs $210,000 less, on the same size lot, with a tax bill $515 a month lower.
People are figuring it out. This is what people mean when they say they want to get away from it all without actually getting away from it all.
And there are only 12 houses for sale right now. So if you like it, don't take long deciding, because you won't win.
#2 — Beacon Falls: and here's how to read a big number
This one is directly behind me and down the hill.
Back in 1898, a father and son started a rubber shoe company here. By 1918 they had 1,500 people working in that factory, and in 1920 about 5.5 million pairs of shoes came out of this little valley.
They hired the Olmsted Brothers — the sons of Frederick Law Olmsted, who designed Central Park — to lay out the neighborhood for the workers up on the hill.
This town still has a train station, Route 8, and one of the best hikes around, right up on High Rock. This is Beacon Falls, and the company was the Beacon Falls Rubber Shoe Company. (There was a tremendous amount of rubber manufacturing in this valley between Naugatuck and Beacon Falls — they made most of it for the whole country.)
I did a whole head-to-head video on this town against Prospect. And since then, look what happened.
The numbers — and the warning
Sales are up 29.7%. The typical house went from $364,000 to $447,250.
Now be careful with that price, because some of it is just bigger houses selling. The headline says about 23%. The price per square foot is up 11.5% — still more than double the state. But it is not 23%.
I don't want you walking around telling people Beacon Falls is up 23% this year.
When you see a big number online, the first thing to ask is: compared to what?
67% of homes sold over asking, up from 46% last year. And there are only nine houses for sale in the entire town. So it's slim pickings. The estimated tax bill is about $795 a month.
People are finding this place.
#1 — Seymour: more buyers, and the price hasn't noticed yet
David Humphreys was George Washington's personal aide during the Revolution. Washington later sent him overseas as a diplomat, and he came home with a flock of Merino sheep.
He brought them to the Naugatuck River and built one of the first big woolen mills in the country. For a while this town was even named after him — Humphreysville.
Now look at what's happening
Last year at this point, 88 homes had sold here. This year, 118. That's up 34% — the most of any town on this list.
And here's the part I told you about. Thirty more houses sold, and the price per square foot did not move.
The typical house sat 20 days, up from seven. So you actually have a minute to think about it.
The typical house price is $433,450. It's right on Route 8, it has a train station, and the estimated tax bill is about $700 a month.
Sales go first and prices go second — and the prices haven't gone yet.
The number one town everybody's moving to is Seymour, Connecticut.
All ten, side by side
| # | Town | County | Typical house | Sales growth | Est. tax/mo | Mill rate | Pace signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | Cheshire | New Haven | $595,000 | +7.5% | ~$1,032 | 29.74 | 8 days, 70% over — buyers piling in |
| 9 | Enfield | Hartford | $350,000 | +7.6% | ~$643 town / ~$707–762 district | 31.50 + district | 7 days, 75% over — buyers piling in |
| 8 | Wolcott | New Haven | $410,000 | +8.1% | ~$859 | 35.93 | psf +11.9% — buyers piling in |
| 7 | Ansonia | New Haven | $385,000 | +8.2% | ~$641 | 28.55 | price flat — hasn't priced in yet |
| 6 | New Milford | Litchfield | $549,450 | +9.7% | ~$992 + lake district | 30.96 | 28 days, 44% over — room to negotiate |
| 5 | Stratford | Fairfield | $492,500 | +14.9% | ~$1,155 | 40.20 | 24 days, was 10 — more sellers |
| 4 | Westbrook | Middlesex | $575,000 | +15.1% | ~$755 + beach assoc. | 22.50 | psf up despite lower median |
| 3 | Bethany | New Haven | $570,000 | +20% | ~$969 | ~29.14 | 12 listings — tight |
| 2 | Beacon Falls | New Haven | $447,250 | +29.7% | ~$795 | ~30.47 | 67% over, was 46%; 9 listings |
| 1 | Seymour | New Haven | $433,450 | +34% | ~$700 | 27.72 | 20 days, was 7 — price hasn't moved |
Statewide, home sales are down about 2% this year. Based on closed single-family sales January through October, compared against the same dates last year; condominiums excluded and very low-volume towns not ranked. Taxes estimated as typical sale price × 0.70 assessment ratio × (mill rate ÷ 1,000). Enfield levies five fire districts plus a tax district, New Milford's lake communities and Westbrook's beach associations levy their own rates — all on top of the town rate. Bethany's and Beacon Falls' rates are derived from the stated monthly figures and should be confirmed.
Three things this table shows you
The #1 town is #1 for the right reason. Seymour has the biggest jump in buyers and a price per square foot that didn't budge and houses sitting nearly three times longer than last year. Those three together are unusual — normally a 34% jump in demand shows up in the price within a year. That gap is the whole opportunity, and it closes.
Two towns on this page are telling you to slow down, not hurry. New Milford at 28 days and 44% over asking, and Stratford at 24 days against last year's 10. Both have rising sales and a slowing pace — which means sellers showed up, not that buyers left. Those are the two where you can actually ask for an inspection.
And the tax column is doing more work than the price column. Ansonia and Shelton land within $9 a month of each other on houses $207,500 apart. Cheshire beats Hamden by $159 a month on a house costing $201,500 more. Twice on this page, the cheaper house is the more expensive one to own. Run the number before you fall in love.
So which one is yours?
If there's a town you can't stop thinking about, text me or call me. I'll give you the real picture of what's happening there — and you'll know something you didn't know before.
We're a family-owned independent brokerage with a team covering the entire state. I love this business, and I'd like you to be a Dave Jones Realty client for life, not for one transaction.
Call or text: 203-910-2638 Email: Dave@davejonesrealty.com Search every home in Connecticut: www.searchallcthomes.com
Market data reflects closed single-family sales reported through SmartMLS from January through October, compared against the same dates in the prior year; condominiums are excluded, very low-volume towns were not ranked, and these figures will age. Where a town's median sale price moved sharply, median price per square foot is cited instead, because a change in the mix of houses sold can move a median price without the market moving at all. Property tax figures are estimates calculated as typical sale price × 0.70 assessment ratio × (mill rate ÷ 1,000); they are not a quote on any individual property, and your actual Connecticut bill depends on that home's assessed value from the town's most recent revaluation and on which taxing district it sits in. Enfield levies five fire districts and a tax district, New Milford's lake communities and Westbrook's beach associations levy additional rates, and many other Connecticut municipalities have similar districts — these do not appear on most listing sites, so always confirm the district for a specific property. Connecticut municipalities must revalue at least every five years, and a lower mill rate following a revaluation is not a tax cut. Flood zone status materially affects the cost of owning near the shoreline; consult FEMA's flood maps and obtain an actual insurance quote before making an offer. Statements about past price or sales movement are history, not a forecast, and nothing here is investment, tax or insurance advice. For school information, see GreatSchools.org and contact the district directly. For public safety information, contact the local police department and review the state's published data yourself. Always conduct independent due diligence on any town and any property before buying.
Dave Jones Realty LLC | Serving Connecticut from offices in Prospect, Watertown, Middletown, and Litchfield