Today we took the show on the road.

I'm Dave Jones with Dave Jones Realty, and I want to show you exactly how far your money goes in Connecticut — using a real house, in a real town, with a real number attached to it.

Here's the game. As you read, keep a running guess in your head on two things: what this house sold for, and what the property taxes are. I'll reveal both at the end.

And that second number is the whole point. One of the biggest pushbacks we hear about Connecticut is the taxes. It's never just the price. It's the price plus the tax that tells you what it actually costs to live somewhere.

Let's go through it.


The house

3,500 square feet. Four bedrooms, two and a half baths. One acre. Built in 1989. Prospect, Connecticut.

It's a traditional floor plan, not the open concept a lot of buyers ask for — but a traditional layout has its own advantage: every room gives you separation. The dining room here is enormous, with room for a full-size table and every leaf you own.

This is a move-up house. Not a first-time buyer property. This is for somebody who had a two-bedroom condo or a small three-bedroom, outgrew it, and is stepping up — usually with a house of their own to sell first. That's exactly what happened here; it went under contract to a move-up buyer.

The living room and the pellet stove

There's a pellet stove in the living room, and if you're new to Connecticut, that detail matters more than you'd think.

Connecticut is consistently one of the highest utility-cost states in the country. Primary heat here is usually oil, propane, or natural gas, and all three are expensive. Being able to supplement changes your winter budget meaningfully.

The stove takes 40-pound bags you keep in the garage. Ours burns about a bag and a half a day — 40 to 60 pounds — and we keep the oil heat off during the winter. In a room like this one, positioned right, it heats the entire level and the heat naturally works its way upstairs.

Reading the floors

The living room and dining room have prefinished hardwood. These almost look too perfect to be real wood, but they are — they're just stained and sealed at the factory rather than on site.

Why it matters: prefinished hardwood can usually be sanded, restained, and resealed. So if you don't love the color, that's a fixable problem, not a replacement.

Upstairs the flooring is different — that's luxury vinyl plank (LVP), sometimes sold as LVT. It has some real wood content but it's primarily a composite, and most of it is waterproof and far more scratch-resistant than hardwood. If you've got dogs, that's a real advantage.

The kitchen

Large eat-in kitchen, granite counters, newer cabinets with black hardware, stainless appliances, bottom freezer, downdraft stove with the fan built into the back, double ovens, undermount sink — and it looks straight out over the backyard, so you can stand at the sink and see what's happening out there.

The French doors have the blinds built between the panes. If you've ever lived with the old-fashioned kind that swing and bang out of alignment every time you close the door, you'll appreciate that.

There's a pantry closet with room for the mixers and the bulk boxes, and the garage is right off this area — pull in, unload, walk it ten feet.

One thing worth flagging. At this price point you'll sometimes see a walk-in pantry. This house doesn't have one. If that's a dealbreaker for you, tell your agent up front.

But here's what I've learned watching people buy: the things people actually walk away over are bedroom count, roof age, and an outdated kitchen. The smaller items — the walk-in pantry, the dedicated office — are usually where people find they can compromise, because there's another space in the house that can do the job.

The main level

A generous coat closet right inside the front door, which sounds minor until you're hosting. A formal living room behind it that would make an excellent home office — and since 2020 that's become one of the most requested features we see. It's on the main level rather than stuck in the basement or a walk-up attic, so you can actually shut the door and work.

Off the garage there's a mudroom area with room for a bench, plus a half bath on the main level.

The bonus room over the garage

This is where a lot of the square footage comes from, and it's flexible — second living room, second primary suite, oversized office, workout room.

It has its own mini-split for air conditioning, which is worth explaining because you'll see both types in Connecticut:

  • Traditional central air — the big compressor outside, ductwork hidden, vents in the floors. Usually paired with forced hot air heat.
  • Mini-splits (Mitsubishi Mr. Slim, Fujitsu, and others) — the wall-mounted units you see in additions or rooms that are hard to duct. They're far more efficient than the old built-in wall units they replaced, many of them heat as well as cool, and they'll condition a space this size quickly.

In Connecticut, central air is close to a must. Once you've had it you'll never go back. But if you're looking at a house without it, don't walk away over that alone — it can almost always be added, and we've got good people for that.

Windows — check the age

On a house from the 80s or 90s, look at whether the windows have been replaced. Original wood windows will eventually need it; vinyl windows will essentially last. If they haven't been done, you want to know so you can budget for it.

And if you're looking at Connecticut's genuinely old houses — the charming 200-year-old properties — you'll notice the glass distorts everything like a funhouse mirror. That's original single-pane glass, sometimes set in leaded came. It's a huge part of the charm and it leaks a tremendous amount of heat. That's a real trade you're making, so go in knowing it.

The garage

Underrated feature in this state, and I talk about it constantly for a reason: the winters are rough. You don't just want your car out of the snow — you want somewhere to keep the snowblower so you can start at the garage and work down the driveway.

Two-car, oversized, automatic openers.

And there's a box on the wall a lot of people can't identify: a transfer switch. That means this house has a generator hookup.

That's genuinely town-dependent. Some subdivisions have underground utilities. Others still run on poles — and where there are poles, storms bring them down and you're out for a day or two. Prospect is a town that loses power fairly often, so generators matter here.


The basement — where the money actually is

We also sell real estate in Florida, where nearly everything is built on slab. In Connecticut, we use this space, and most larger colonials from this era have a full basement.

This one's finished — a music room, a workout area, a laundry room with ceramic tile, nice ceilings, casement windows for light.

A note on finished basement bedrooms. You'd assume a window plus a closet makes it a bedroom. In towns on septic, that's not what governs it — the septic tank size does. Bedroom count is tied to tank capacity under the state health code, so adding a bedroom can mean upsizing the tank. How you use the room is up to you, but if you want it classified as a bedroom for resale, that has to be done properly with the town and permitted.

The utility room, in plain English

This is where I like to start on any showing, because if a house doesn't get past what's down here, nothing upstairs matters. This is where the money in a house lives.

The water heater. You'll have either an electric unit or a domestic coil off the boiler. Check that it's sized for the number of people who'll live there — and check the age. Typical life is 10 to 15 years, so you want to know what you're walking into.

The boiler. Look at the fittings. When I walk in and see a lot of well-made connections, multiple zones, copper piping done right, I know the owner invested here. That tells you something about how the rest of the house was cared for.

The oil tank. And let me push back on something I hear constantly: "I don't want oil heat."

Oil heat is not the enemy. You just have to budget for it and manage it. Buy oil in the summer when it's cheaper. Add a second tank — this one looks to be around 330 gallons, so a second gets you 660 gallons bought at summer pricing, which will carry most of a winter in a smaller house. In a house this size you'd still fill a couple of times, but supplement with a pellet stove and it hurts a lot less when Scott Phillips from Phillips Oil, our local guy here in Prospect, pulls up.

The white pipe running up the wall — that's a radon mitigation system. More on that below, because it deserves its own section.

The well equipment. In Connecticut, plenty of homes are on well rather than city water. Water comes up from the well into a holding tank, which stores it until you need it. Turn on a shower upstairs and you'll hear it kick on, release, and refill.

Next to it is a water softener. In towns like Prospect you'll often have hard water, and a softener treats it so it's easier on your pipes and fixtures.

Even with all the mechanicals tucked into the unfinished portion, there's still real storage down here on top of all the finished space.


Upstairs

At this price point you should expect a generous primary bedroom with a walk-in closet and its own bath — that's part of what separates a move-up house from a starter house.

This one delivers: room for a king plus a work area, a closet with built-ins already installed, and an updated primary bath.

That last part is worth real money. If you're looking at a house with a dated primary bath, budget $15,000 to $30,000 for a mid-range full bath update — tile shower, tile floor, decent but not high-end finishes. Go high-end and that number can easily double. Here it's already done.

The other rooms

Three of the bedrooms have carpet, which you'll see a lot of in Connecticut. Harsh winters make warm floors underfoot in the morning genuinely nice.

Here's a useful trick. In a house built in the 80s or later, carpet is probably over plywood. In a house from the 70s or earlier, there's often hardwood underneath. Peek in the closets — if they didn't carpet the closet, you can usually see exactly what you're working with.

The hall bath is generous with two sinks, a new vanity, and new mirrors.

And there's a contraption in the hallway ceiling people always ask about: a whole-house fan. Connecticut isn't humid year-round — spring and fall evenings are genuinely beautiful. You open the downstairs windows, flip the switch, and it pulls that cool air through the entire house. It's a great feature to have.

Small things worth noticing that you won't find in every house at this price: ceiling fans (for the nights that are warm but not central-air warm), chair rail in two bedrooms (keeps beds and desks from scuffing the walls, and adds character), and raised six-panel doors rather than the flat hollow-core doors common to this era. If it were mine, I'd swap the nickel hinges and handles for black to match what they did in the kitchen — instant upgrade, minimal cost.

There are also pull-down attic stairs. Once you're shopping in the 2,500 to 3,000+ square foot range you need storage — finished basement, shed, attic — and pull-down stairs beat hauling out a ladder every December.

One more trick while you're up here: look out the window at the roof. You get a view you can't get from the ground. Read the property condition disclosure for the owner's stated roof age, but your own eyes won't lie.


Outside

The lot is about an acre, which you'll see a lot of in Prospect. Some newer subdivisions here have two-acre minimums; older properties run an acre or a half.

But acreage isn't the whole story — placement is. There's privacy to the right, to the left, and behind. If privacy matters to you, we can often rule properties in or out before you ever get in the car, just using Street View and satellite imagery. Is it a shared driveway? Are the neighbors right on top of the back deck? If that's a dealbreaker, don't spend a Saturday finding out in person.

Decking and siding

Decks in Connecticut come two ways. Wood — pressure-treated or painted, like this one — or composite like Azek or Trex. Composite runs three to four times the cost up front, and then you never think about it again. A painted wood deck needs repainting every 5 to 10 years.

Siding is the same trade. Aluminum, wood, or vinyl. Vinyl is the low-maintenance choice short of brick. Wood means staining, painting, and an ongoing battle — and I know, because I owned one.

The battle is with carpenter bees. They find wood siding, drill their perfectly round holes, and lay their eggs. The bees themselves aren't what wrecks the house. The damage comes from woodpeckers, who consider those eggs a delicacy and will tear the siding apart getting to them.

So if you're looking at wood shake siding, know there's upkeep attached. We've got good exterminators, and good people for vinyl siding.

Also check the gutters. Make sure they're there and that water is being carried away from the foundation. Connecticut winters bring ice damming, so heated gutters are worth considering.

Ledge and radon

Connecticut has a lot of ledge — exposed bedrock. You can see it all around this property, and it makes for beautiful natural landscaping and a built-in privacy barrier.

But know where your ledge is if you have plans. Thinking about an addition or an in-ground pool? Ledge can mean blasting, and that changes the math on a project considerably.

And ledge often comes with radon. Radon is a naturally occurring gas — it's in the air around us right now. The concern is when it accumulates inside a house. It's the leading cause of lung cancer among non-smokers and the second-leading cause overall, after smoking.

Prospect has high radon levels, largely because of all this rock.

This house has a mitigation system — that white pipe from the basement. It draws air from beneath the slab and vents it above the roofline, continuously.

Now let me be precise here, because this is health information and it matters. A mitigation system does not mean radon is impossible. It means the level is being actively managed. Systems can lose performance, and fans do fail. The EPA recommends retesting every two years, and after any major renovation. So a working system is genuinely good news — it just isn't a permanent guarantee, and you should confirm it's functioning and see the most recent test results.

Don't let radon be a dealbreaker. It's a manageable, well-understood problem with good remediation companies available. Just know it exists here and test for it.


So — what's the number?

3,500 square feet. Four bedrooms, two and a half baths. Finished basement. An acre of land. Central air. Updated kitchen. Bonus room over a two-car garage. Three finished levels.

The list price: $629,900.

And the tax reveal

The 2026 property taxes on this house come in at $8,700.

For a 3,500 square foot home on an acre, that's a genuinely reasonable number — and it's a big part of why Prospect is the town it is.

Here's the comparison that should stick with you. Take a house at this same price point and put it in a neighboring town like Waterbury or Wolcott, and the tax bill could easily run around $13,000 a year.

Same purchase price. Same monthly mortgage. A difference of roughly $350 to $400 a month, every month, forever.

That's the whole argument I make on nearly every call. Two houses can carry the identical listing price and cost completely different amounts to own. You have to see the whole picture before you fall in love with a floor plan.

One important note on how this works. Your tax bill is calculated on the town's assessed value, not on what you paid. The formula is:

Assessed value (70% of appraised value) × mill rate ÷ 1,000

That's why the tax on a specific house doesn't always track cleanly to its sale price. And it's why you should confirm the actual current figure on any specific property before you write an offer — especially in a town that has recently gone through a revaluation, since a reval can change both the assessment and the mill rate at the same time. Don't rely on the tax figure printed on a listing sheet. Ask, and verify with the town.


Let's find yours

If you're making a move in Connecticut — buying here, selling here, or heading out of state — call the team at Dave Jones Realty. We've got over 150 agents and five offices, and we're on pace to sell 700 houses this year.

Book a Zoom with me directly and I'll pair you with the right agent.

Call or text: 203-910-2638 Email: Dave@davejonesrealty.com Search every home in Connecticut: www.searchallcthomes.com


This property was under contract at the time of filming; details are shared for illustration. Tax figures reflect the 2026 bill on this specific property and are not a guide to what any other property will owe. Mill rates are set annually and revaluations can change assessments significantly. Renovation cost ranges are general estimates and vary by scope and contractor. Radon, septic, well, and structural information here is educational and is not a substitute for professional inspection and testing. For school information, we recommend GreatSchools.org and visiting districts directly. Buyers researching any Connecticut community should conduct their own independent due diligence on all factors relevant to their decision.

 

Dave Jones Realty LLC | Serving New Haven, Hartford, and Litchfield Counties